Beautyrest vs Saatva: In-Depth Mattress Comparison Guide 2023

In the world of luxury mattresses, two brands stand out: Beautyrest and Saatva. As you search for the perfect mattress, it’s essential to compare and analyze these two industry leaders. Each brand has unique advantages, but ultimately, the choice comes down to your preferences and sleep needs.

One key difference between the two brands is their availability. Saatva operates exclusively online, offering a direct-to-consumer approach that can often lead to better deals. On the other hand, Beautyrest mattresses can be purchased online and in physical retail stores, allowing you to test the bed before buying. Moreover, Saatva offers three firmness options, while Beautyrest offers a medium-firm option with a comfort upgrade to soften the feel.

When it comes to construction, Saatva combines memory foam with innerspring elements, leaning towards the innerspring side in its 11.5″ design. Beautyrest, known for its hybrid construction, offers both premium and affordable beds with strong hybrid designs. As you weigh the pros and cons of these two renowned brands, consider factors such as where you’d like to purchase, firmness preferences, and construction materials to find the ideal sleep solution for you.

Saatva vs Beautyrest: Brand Overview

When comparing Saatva and Beautyrest, it’s important to understand their brand backgrounds and offerings.

Saatva is a relatively newer player in the mattress industry, having been established in 2010. They operate on a direct-to-consumer model, which means their mattresses can only be purchased online. This setup allows Saatva to offer better deals and lower prices to their customers. The company is known for providing luxury, eco-friendly mattresses that cater to a variety of sleep preferences.

Beautyrest is a brand that falls under the Simmons Bedding Company, a well-known and established bedding industry player founded in 1870. With a rich history and diverse range of products, Beautyrest mattresses are available both online and at physical retail locations. The Beautyrest Black, a high-end hybrid mattress, stands out for its combination of cushioning foams and a pocketed coil support system.

When comparing these two brands, a few key differences are observed:

• Availability: Saatva mattresses can only be purchased online, while Beautyrest beds are available both online and in-store at various retailers.
• Product Line: Saatva offers a more limited selection of mattress models compared to the extensive range from Beautyrest.
• Price Range: Saatva’s direct-to-consumer model allows them to offer slightly better deals than Beautyrest, which may be a deciding factor for budget-conscious shoppers.
• Cooling Features: Both Saatva and Beautyrest mattresses are designed to provide a cool night’s sleep, catering to hot sleepers and combination sleepers.
• Construction: Saatva mattresses feature a memory foam and innerspring hybrid construction, while Beautyrest, such as the Black model, is a high-end hybrid mattress using cushioning foams and a pocketed coil support layer.

While both brands have their own unique offerings and features, it’s essential to consider your personal preferences, needs, and budget when choosing between Saatva and Beautyrest. You might want to focus on factors like the ideal support level, how the mattress feels, and whether it has cooling features that suit your sleep style.

Mattress Types and Materials

Innerspring

Innerspring mattresses are traditional, consisting primarily of steel coils for support. These mattresses offer a responsive, bouncy feel and great air circulation, keeping you cool throughout the night. The Beautyrest Black model uses pocketed coils for targeted support and reduced motion transfer, while Saatva’s luxury coil-on-coil design provides excellent durability and pressure relief, ensuring a comfortable sleep.

Memory Foam

Memory foam mattresses contour to your body, providing personalized support and pressure relief. While neither the Saatva nor the Beautyrest Black is a pure memory foam mattress, they both incorporate foam layers for added comfort. The Beautyrest Black, for example, has four layers (3.5″) of various foams.

Hybrid Mattress

Hybrid mattresses combine the benefits of innerspring and memory foam, typically featuring a pocketed coil support system and one or more layers of foam for comfort. Both the Saatva and the Beautyrest Black can be considered hybrid mattresses, offering a mix of coil systems and foam layers. This design delivers a balanced feel, with responsiveness from the innerspring coils and pressure relief from the foam layers.

Mattress	Support System	Foam Layers
Saatva	Coil-on-coil	3″ pillow top layer
Beautyrest Black	Pocketed coils	Four layers (3.5″) of various foams

Organic

Organic materials like organic cotton can be found in some mattresses for eco-friendly and health-conscious consumers. While neither the Saatva nor the Beautyrest Black explicitly focuses on organic materials in their construction, shoppers seeking more natural options may want to explore other mattress lines or consider an organic mattress protector to pair with their chosen bed.

To recap:

• Innerspring mattresses use steel coils for support and bounce.
• Memory foam mattresses provide contouring support and pressure relief.
• Hybrid mattresses, like the Saatva and Beautyrest Black, combine innerspring and foam elements for a balanced feel.
• Organic mattresses or accessories cater to eco-friendly shoppers.

Construction and Design

When comparing the Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses, it is essential to consider the construction and design elements that contribute to their overall performance and comfort.

Starting with the Beautyrest mattress, it has a combination of various foams and innerspring coils in its construction. One of the key features of this mattress is the innovative ContourFit Design. This design allows the mattress to conform closely to your body, providing tailored support and pressure relief. Additionally, the Pocketed Coil system enhances the responsive nature of the mattress, ensuring that your movements are well-supported throughout the night.

On the other hand, the Saatva mattress utilizes a unique “coil-on-coil” construction to provide a balanced and comfortable sleeping surface. This design features a support base made of tempered recycled steel coils, which offer durability and resistance to sagging. The coil system also enhances the mattress’s responsiveness, making it suitable for various sleep positions.

One notable aspect of Saatva mattresses is the incorporation of a Euro Pillow Top. This pillow top is made from 100% organic cotton, giving the surface a breathable, soft feel. It also adds a layer of cushioning to the mattress, ensuring that you experience a comfortable and pressure-relieving sleep.

In summary, both Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses showcase unique construction and design elements to support a comfortable and restful sleep. By understanding these features, you can decide which mattress will best suit your needs and preferences.

Firmness and Comfort Options

In this section, we’ll cover the firmness and comfort options available for both Saatva and Beautyrest mattresses. We’ll break down each brand’s offerings, discussing the various options regarding firmness, comfort, and pressure relief.

Saatva

Saatva offers a range of mattress firmness options to cater to your personal preferences and sleep habits. These options include:

• Plush Soft: If you prefer a softer mattress, this option will provide you with a cloud-like feel and ample pressure relief.
• Luxury Firm: This option offers a balance between comfort and support, making it a popular choice among consumers. Luxury firm mattresses conform to your body while maintaining their shape to keep your spine properly aligned.
• Firm: This option provides solid support and limited sinkage for those who prefer a firmer mattress with minimal contouring.

Saatva Mattresses deliver excellent pressure relief to accommodate various sleep preferences by combining layers of responsive coil-on-coil structure and adaptive memory foam. This ensures you’ll receive necessary support and comfort regardless of your chosen firmness level.

Beautyrest

Beautyrest’s flagship model, the Beautyrest Black, is available with medium firmness, falling around a 6 on the firmness scale. This medium-firm option suits those who like a balance of comfort and support. Moreover, Beautyrest Black offers a comfort upgrade to soften the feel of the mattress slightly. This upgrade is appropriate for those seeking added plushness without compromising the mattress’s inherent support and durability.

Although Beautyrest doesn’t offer the same range of options as Saatva, their medium-firm mattresses provide adequate pressure relief and spine alignment. The blend of comfort and support caters to various sleep preferences and promotes a restful night’s sleep.

In conclusion, consider your preferences regarding firmness and comfort when choosing between Saatva and Beautyrest. Both brands offer mattresses designed to provide proper support, pressure relief, and a comfortable sleep experience.

Cooling and Breathability

When it comes to cooling and breathability, both Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses have features that ensure you stay comfortable throughout the night. These mattresses focus on providing proper airflow and temperature regulation through various cooling technologies and breathable materials.

In the case of Beautyrest, their innerspring coils effectively sweep away excess body heat, preventing you from overheating while sleeping. Additionally, the cooling technologies in the cover and foam layers actively work to regulate your temperature. In particular, the AirCool Memory Foam found in Beautyrest mattresses conforms to your body and allows air to circulate more freely, contributing to the overall cooling effect.

On the other hand, Saatva incorporates a combination of memory foam and innerspring materials in their hybrid design. Both mattresses have coil layers as their foundation, which encourages airflow through the core, making them cooler than all-foam or memory foam mattresses alone. Moreover, Saatva’s cover is made from 100% organic cotton, giving the surface a breathable and soft feel.

To sum things up, you will find that both Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses prioritize cooling and breathability to maintain a comfortable sleep environment. With mindful features like innerspring coils, cooling technologies, and AirCool memory foam, these mattresses work hard to ensure that you stay cool throughout the night.

Motion Isolation and Edge Support

When comparing the Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses, motion isolation and edge support are essential factors to consider, especially if you share your bed with a partner and want to ensure minimal disturbance.

Motion Isolation: Both Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses offer good motion isolation. This means that when your partner moves or changes positions, you are less likely to be disturbed. While both brands perform well in this area, Saatva may offer slightly better motion isolation due to its thick coil system and memory foam layers.

Edge Support: A mattress with reinforced edges allows you to use the full surface area of your bed without feeling like you’re going to fall off. In this regard, the Beautyrest Hybrid has an advantage, as it features a sturdy edge-to-edge support system that’s highly durable, thanks to its ultra-thick coil system. Saatva offers decent edge support, but it may be less robust than the support found in the Beautyrest mattress.

To sum up, both the Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses provide commendable motion isolation and edge support. However, the Beautyrest Hybrid may have an edge (pun intended) in the edge support department, while Saatva may offer slightly better motion isolation. It’s important to consider both of these factors when making your decision to ensure that you choose the best mattress that fulfills your personal sleep preferences and requirements.

Pricing and Size Options

In this section, we will discuss the pricing and size options for both Saatva and Beautyrest mattresses to help you make an informed decision.

Saatva

Saatva offers a wide range of mattress sizes, including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Split King. The prices for these mattresses vary depending on the size you choose:

• Twin: $887
• Twin XL: $1,148
• Full: $1,595
• Queen: $1,695
• King: $2,095
• Split King: $2,296

It’s important to note that Saatva’s mattresses tend to be lighter in weight compared to Beautyrest’s. This might be a consideration for you, especially if you plan to move the mattress frequently or have difficulty lifting heavy objects.

Beautyrest

Beautyrest offers a variety of mattress sizes as well, including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Split King. The prices for their mattresses are generally higher than Saatva’s:

• Twin: $1,299
• Twin XL: $1,499
• Full: $1,699
• Queen: $1,899
• King: $2,399
• Split King: $2,998

Beautyrest mattresses are known for their premium materials and construction, which can result in a heavier weight. This might make it more challenging to move or lift, but it can also provide a more luxurious feel and added durability.

In summary, both Saatva and Beautyrest offer a variety of mattress sizes and pricing options to suit your needs. While Saatva tends to be more affordable and lighter in weight, Beautyrest offers a more luxurious feel and durability. Consider these factors when choosing the best mattress for your needs.

Sleep Trials, Warranty, and Shipping

When considering the purchase of a Beautyrest or Saatva mattress, you’ll naturally want to know about their sleep trial periods, warranty policies, and shipping details. Having a good understanding of these aspects will help you make a well-informed decision.

Sleep Trial Period

Both Beautyrest and Saatva offer trial periods that allow you to experience their mattresses in your own home before committing fully. With Saatva, you’re granted a generous 365-night home trial. In contrast, Beautyrest provides a slightly shorter trial period of 100 nights. These trials give you ample time to determine if the mattress is right for your needs and preferences.

Warranty

When it comes to warranty coverage, Saatva stands out with an impressive lifetime warranty on their mattresses. This policy reflects the brand’s confidence in the quality and durability of their products. On the other hand, Beautyrest offers a more standard 10-year warranty, which is still a good duration to protect your investment.

Shipping and Delivery

Both Saatva and Beautyrest take care of shipping costs for their mattresses, meaning there is free shipping on your purchase. Additionally, Saatva offers free White Glove delivery service for all customers. This service includes the setup of your new mattress and the removal of your old one, ensuring a hassle-free experience.

In summary, when comparing Beautyrest and Saatva’s sleep trials, warranty, and shipping, Saatva offers a longer home trial period and more extensive warranty coverage. They also include a convenient White Glove delivery service at no extra charge. On the other hand, Beautyrest provides a decent trial period and warranty, as well as free shipping. Keep these factors in mind as you decide which mattress brand is the best fit for your needs.

Comparing Saatva Models

When it comes to Saatva mattresses, there are three main models to consider: the Saatva Classic, Saatva HD, and Saatva Latex Hybrid. Each of these models has unique features that cater to different sleep preferences and needs.

Saatva Classic is a luxury innerspring mattress available in three firmness levels: plush soft, luxury firm (medium), and firm. This model offers a good balance of comfort and support with its combination of memory foam, individually wrapped coils, and a durable steel coil base. Here are some key features of the Saatva Classic:

• Eco-friendly materials such as organic cotton and CertiPUR-US certified foams
• Individually wrapped comfort coils for motion isolation
• Reinforced steel coil support system for added durability and edge support
• Suitable for all sleep positions and most body types

Saatva HD is designed specifically for people with larger body types, providing enhanced support and durability. With its zoned latex layer, high-density memory foam, and extra-strong steel coils, the Saatva HD can comfortably accommodate sleepers weighing between 300 and 500 pounds. Key features of the Saatva HD include:

• Zoned Talalay latex for targeted pressure relief and spinal alignment
• High-density memory foam for added contouring and durability
• 12.5-gauge tempered steel coils for exceptional support
• Best suited for back and stomach sleepers, as well as heavyweight sleepers

Lastly, the Saatva Latex Hybrid combines the benefits of Talalay latex and pocketed coils for an all-natural, hypoallergenic sleep surface. This mattress offers a medium firmness level and is suitable for most sleep positions. Some notable features of the Saatva Latex Hybrid are:

• 100% natural Talalay latex for a responsive and pressure-relieving sleep surface
• Organic cotton cover for a soft and breathable touch
• Individually wrapped pocketed coils for excellent motion isolation and support
• Ideal for eco-conscious shoppers and those with allergies or sensitivities

In summary, the Saatva Classic caters to a wide range of sleep preferences and needs, while the Saatva HD is built for heavyweight sleepers seeking extra support. The Saatva Latex Hybrid is a great option for those looking for a natural and hypoallergenic mattress.

Comparing Beautyrest Models

When comparing Beautyrest models, it’s essential to consider your personal preferences and sleeping needs. Beautyrest offers a range of mattresses, including the Beautyrest Black, Beautyrest Black Hybrid, and Beautyrest Hybrid models.

The Beautyrest Black is a luxury mattress featuring T3 pocketed coil technology, which provides superior support and pressure relief. This mattress has different firmness levels, so you can choose a model that caters to your comfort preferences. With the infusion of memory foam layers, this mattress helps keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night.

The Beautyrest Black Hybrid combines the best of both worlds, featuring the T3 pocketed coils found in the Beautyrest Black along with multiple layers of memory foam. This mattress is designed to provide a perfect balance of comfort and support, making it an excellent choice for sleepers seeking pressure relief and targeted support. Additionally, it has a cooling cover that ensures a comfortable sleep temperature.

The Beautyrest Hybrid is another option within the Beautyrest lineup. It too features pocketed coil technology paired with memory foam layers. The difference lies in the overall construction and feel of the mattress. The Beautyrest Hybrid offers a more traditional mattress feel compared to the Black Hybrid, providing an excellent balance of comfort and support.

To make an informed decision, consider your specific needs:

• Firmness: Do you prefer a softer or firmer mattress? Both Beautyrest Black and Beautyrest Hybrid offer various firmness options to suit your preferences.
• Sleeping Position: If you are a side sleeper, you may want a mattress with more contouring, while back and stomach sleepers may prefer a firmer option for added support.
• Temperature Regulation: If you tend to sleep hot, opt for a mattress with cooling technologies, such as the Beautyrest Black or Beautyrest Black Hybrid.

By evaluating these factors, you can determine which Beautyrest model aligns best with your sleep preferences and requirements.

Customer Service and Additional Services

When considering a mattress company, customer service plays an essential role in your overall satisfaction. Both Beautyrest and Saatva place importance on offering efficient and friendly customer support.

Saatva, being a direct-to-consumer company, operates exclusively online. This setup allows them to provide better deals and streamline their services. Saatva’s customer service is known for being responsive and helpful. You can reach them through phone, email, or online chat.

In addition to standard customer support, Saatva offers:

• A 180-night trial period
• Free white glove delivery and setup
• A 15-year warranty
• Optional mattress removal services

Beautyrest, on the other hand, sells both online and through physical retailers. This can provide some benefits in terms of trying out products before buying and potentially additional in-store customer support. Beautyrest strives to give a pleasant customer experience, and they can be contacted through phone and email.

Additional services provided by Beautyrest include:

• A 100-night trial period
• Free standard shipping
• A 10-year warranty
• White glove delivery (at an additional cost)

When it comes to exchanges, both companies offer trial periods that allow you to test out the mattress and, if necessary, return the product for a refund within the given time frame. Remember to always read the fine print regarding returns, exchanges, and warranty claims to avoid any misunderstandings.

Conclusion

When comparing Beautyrest and Saatva mattresses, it’s essential to consider your personal preferences and needs. Both brands might satisfy your requirements if you’re looking for high-quality mattresses with multiple firmness options.

Saatva offers a luxury coil-on-coil innerspring mattress that provides pressure-relieving comfort layers and a durable support system. On the other hand, Beautyrest Black features a deluxe innerspring mattress with pressure-relieving foam, latex layers, and supportive pocketed coils. While both brands offer exceptional and comfortable options, your final choice may depend on factors like availability and budget.

Since Saatva is a direct-to-consumer brand available only online, they are often able to offer more competitive pricing than Beautyrest, which can be found in both online and physical retail locations. Nevertheless, both brands consistently rank as some of the best mattresses and cater to a wide variety of sleeping preferences and needs.

To make an informed decision, carefully consider your sleeping position, desired firmness level, and budget. With either a Saatva or Beautyrest mattress, you’ll likely experience a comfortable and restorative sleep that will leave you well-rested and rejuvenated for the day ahead.