Finding the perfect mattress that meets your comfort, support, and budget needs can be challenging with so many options on the market. The Helix Midnight Luxe and Beautyrest Black are two popular mattress models that frequently top the lists of side sleepers and those looking for a luxury feel.
This extensive comparison examines all aspects of these two mattresses to help you determine the best choice for your individual sleep needs and preferences.
Overview of the Helix and Beautyrest Brands
Helix Sleep launched in 2015 as an online, direct-to-consumer mattress brand. They differentiate themselves through advanced customization options, offering a variety of hybrid and foam mattresses designed for specific sleep positions and preferences. The Helix Midnight Luxe sits at the top end of their product line.
Beautyrest is a longstanding brand by Simmons Bedding Company with a reputation for luxury and innovative coil mattresses. The Beautyrest Black line represents the pinnacle of their offerings, incorporating advanced pocketed coil systems and proprietary foams.
Both companies offer premium mattresses, but Helix emphasizes customization while Beautyrest focuses on advanced support technology.
Comparing the Helix Midnight Luxe vs Beautyrest Black
The Helix Midnight Luxe and Beautyrest Black are the luxury flagships from each brand. Let’s look at how they compare construction, firmness, fees, and other key mattress factors.
Materials and Construction
Helix Midnight Luxe Construction:
- Soft, breathable cover with special cooling yarns
- 2.5 lb memory foam comfort layer for pressure relief
- Transition layer of Helix Dynamic Foam
- Hundreds of wrapped coils for support and responsiveness
- High-density base foam for durability and shape
Beautyrest Black Construction:
- Plush BlackIce cooling cover
- Surface comfort foams including gel memory foam
- Pocketed coil support core with foam encasement
- Foam perimeter for edge support
Both mattresses feature coil support cores surrounded by comfort foams, but the Helix uses memory foam while Beautyrest incorporates a mix of proprietary foams. The Helix cover also has more cooling elements.
Firmness and Feel
The Helix Midnight Luxe rates around a 6 to 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the firmest. This medium feel balances contouring comfort and underlying support.
The Beautyrest Black comes in multiple firmness options. The medium model rates around a 7 to 8 firmness level, offering a slightly firmer and more supportive feel.
A key strength of the Helix Midnight Luxe is its pressure-relieving capabilities. Its memory foam comfort layer contours to the curves of your body, cushioning areas like the shoulders and hips. This makes it an excellent choice for side sleepers.
While the Beautyrest Black has some initial cushioning from its surface foams, its overall firmer and more supportive feel may not provide the same level of pressure relief for some.
Both mattresses incorporate covers designed to promote airflow and coolness. The Helix also contains unique cooling yarns to regulate temperature better and keep you comfortable all night.
The Beautyrest Black’s coil system gives it extra bounce and responsiveness. This makes it easier to change positions during the night. The Helix Midnight Luxe conforms more closely for a “hugged” feel.
Mattresses with strong edge support allow you to sleep near the perimeter without feeling like you’ll roll off. Beautyrest adds reinforced foam encasement around their coil system for superior edge support compared to the all-foam edges of the Helix.
The Helix Midnight Luxe’s individually-wrapped coils are quiet and minimize motion transfer between sleep partners. The Beautyrest pocketed coils are also quite quiet, although some models feature plastic reinforcements that may increase noise potential.
Sizes and Dimensions
Both mattresses come in standard mattress sizes, ranging from Twin to California King. The thickness is 12″ for a Queen Helix Midnight Luxe and 13.5″ for a Queen Beautyrest Black.
You can pair these mattresses with a box spring, slatted base, platform bed, or adjustable base. A solid, supportive foundation may be preferred for the firmer Beautyrest Black.
With their high-density foams and thick coil layers, both mattresses rate well for durability, averaging around 7 to 10 years of lifespan before needing replacement. Their strong construction means they are a long term investment.
Comparing Additional Features and Services
The Helix Midnight Luxe and Beautyrest Black both provide high-end features and conveniences beyond pure comfort and support. Here’s how they stack up.
Helix offers a 100 night sleep trial period while Beautyrest recently increased their trial to 100 nights as well, giving you time to test out the mattress at home.
Both mattresses come with 10 year limited warranties, providing you assurance against defects. But the Helix warranty fully covers indentations greater than 1″ while Beautyrest covers indentations greater than 1.5″.
Helix and Beautyrest both offer financing programs through Klarna that allow you to pay for your mattress over time in manageable monthly installments.
Helix sells basic foundations starting under $250. Beautyrest foundations cost over $300. But both companies let you choose your own foundation if preferred.
Old Mattress Removal
Optional in-home mattress removal and recycling of your old mattress is available through both brands when purchasing a new mattress. Fees apply.
Helix provides free standard delivery to the 48 contiguous states. Beautyrest also offers free standard delivery in these locations. White glove delivery is optional for an added fee.
Returns are free for both companies. They will coordinate pickup and donation or recycling of the mattress if you are unsatisfied during the trial period.
Helix Midnight Luxe Pros and Cons
Helix Midnight Luxe Pros
- Exceptional pressure relief and motion isolation
- 100 night risk-free trial period
- Targeted at side sleepers for comfort
- Breathable, cooling cover promotes airflow
- Responsive customer service
Helix Midnight Luxe Cons
- Only medium firmness option
- Some complaints of sleeping hot
- Lacks edge support due to all-foam sides
- Heavier than some mattress options
Beautyrest Black Pros and Cons
Beautyrest Black Pros
- Strong edge support for sleeping near the perimeter
- Plush yet supportive feel
- Many firmness options to choose from
- Durable and long lasting construction
- Brand name recognition and reputation
Beautyrest Black Cons
- Expensive, higher than average price point
- May sleep warm due to thick construction
- Not targeted for side sleepers specifically
- Some models make noise from plastic reinforcements
Helix Midnight Luxe vs Beautyrest Black: Which is Better for You?
Now that we’ve compared all aspects of the Helix Midnight Luxe and Beautyrest Black mattresses, how do you decide which model may be the right choice for you?
Here are some key questions to ask yourself:
- Do you sleep predominantly on your side? The Helix may provide superior pressure relief.
- Do you tend to sleep hot? The Helix sleeps cooler.
- Do you prefer a firm or plush mattress? The Beautyrest offers multiple firmness choices.
- Are you on a tight budget? The Helix is generally more affordable.
- Do you want strong edge support? The Beautyrest has better reinforced edges.
- Do you value customization? Helix offers more flexibility.
- How long do you want your mattress to last? Both should last over 7 years.
Think carefully about your sleep position, firmness preference, mattress needs, and budget. Read reviews and test them out during a sleep trial to decide if the contouring comfort of the Helix Midnight Luxe or the luxurious support of the Beautyrest Black is the best mattress choice for you.
Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress: Full Review and Details
Helix revolutionized the mattress industry with their fully customizable beds. As their most luxurious model, the Helix Midnight Luxe hybrid mattress provides medium firmness and conforming comfort perfect for side sleepers and those wanting the ultimate pressure relief.
What Makes the Helix Midnight Luxe Stand Out?
Targeted Design: Specifically engineered to alleviate pressure points while supporting proper spinal alignment for side sleepers.
Enhanced Cooling: Breathable cover and heat-conducting foams keep the surface cooler.
Responsive Feel: Dynamic foam and wrapped coils adapt to your body’s contours but don’t restrict movement.
Premium Materials: High-density memory foam and supportive coils offer comfort, pressure relief, and durability.
Construction and Composition
Here’s what makes up the 12″ profile of the Helix Midnight Luxe mattress:
Cover: Soft, breathable polyester fabric with special cooling yarns
Comfort Layer: 2.5 lb memory foam cradles your body to relieve pressure
Transition Layer: 2″ of Helix Dynamic Foam recovers quickly and prevents sagging
Support Layer: 6″ of wrapped coils provide contouring support and minimize motion transfer
Base Layer: Durable 1.5″ high-density polyfoam for stability and shape
Firmness, Feel and Support
With a 6 to 7 rating on the 10 point firmness scale, the Helix Midnight Luxe has a medium feel. The initial memory foam comfort layer softens and contours to the sleeper while the coil layer provides firmer underlying support.
Most sleepers feel properly supported by this balance of cushioning and support. The coils also promote healthy spinal alignment in all positions.
A standout feature of the Helix Midnight Luxe is its superior pressure relief, especially for side sleepers. The memory foam gently cradles shoulders, hips, and other pressure points to reduce discomfort on joints.
The medium firmness further allows your body to sink in for a “hugged” feel rather than pushing against the surface.
Temperature Control and Airflow
Hot sleepers can rest easy on the Helix Midnight Luxe. The moisture-wicking cover promotes airflow while the specially engineered foams are designed to conduct heat away from the body.
The coil layer also allows for increased breathability compared to an all-foam mattress.
Responsiveness and Bounce
The dynamic foam transition layer provides some bounce and responsiveness to changes in position during the night. However, you won’t experience the same buoyant, responsive feel as with innerspring mattresses due to the deep contouring of the memory foam top layer.
One downside of the Helix Midnight Luxe is weaker edge support due to its all-foam layers around the perimeter. The coils themselves are wrapped from edge to edge, but you may notice some sinkage and feel less secure sitting near the sides.
This hybrid’s hundreds of individual pocket coils move independently to isolate motion extremely well. The coils are also wrapped to prevent squeaking and moving against each other, making this a virtually silent mattress.
The close conforming of memory foam may restrict movement somewhat during sex. However, the responsiveness of the micro coils and dynamic foam layer provides enough bounce for a satisfactory experience.
Off-gassing and Smell
Some owners detect an initial “new mattress” smell with the Helix Midnight Luxe. But any off-gassing odors from the foams should dissipate within a few days.
Based on customer experiences, here’s how the Helix Midnight Luxe is rated for different sleeper types:
Side Sleepers: 5/5 stars. Side sleepers sink in for superior pressure relief on the shoulders and hips.
Back Sleepers: 4/5 stars. The medium feel still cradles the lower back comfortably.
Stomach Sleepers: 3.5/5 stars. Though some heavier individuals may want added support.
Plus-size Sleepers: 4/5 stars. Provides excellent contouring for larger bodies.
Combination Sleepers: 4/5 stars. Dynamic foam allows changing positions while memory foam prevents sagging.
Beautyrest Black Mattress: Overview and model details
Beautyrest Black is the premium line by Simmons, featuring advanced coil systems and luxurious designs. We’ll look closely at the Medium model to help you decide if this luxury innerspring mattress offers the experience you seek.
What Makes the Beautyrest Black Stand Out?
Pocketed Coils: 1000+ individually wrapped innerspring coils promote airflow and minimize motion transfer.
Plush Surface Layers: Proprietary foams provide initial comfort and support before the firmer coils are engaged.
Solid Edge Support: Reinforced perimeter maintains sleep space and lets you sit comfortably on the side.
High Profile Design: At 13.5″ thick, this mattress indulges with plush top layers above a tall support core.
Composition and Construction
Here is what makes up the layers under the cooling cover:
Comfort Layer: Gel memory foam and proprietary Beautyrest foams
Support Layer: 1000+ pocketed coils featuring Beautyrest’s Advanced Pocketed Coil Technology
Base Layer: Thin foam layer reinforces edges plus a foam perimeter for added edge support
Mattress Cover: Features moisture-wicking fibers to help keep sleepers cool and dry
Firmness, Support, and Feel
The Beautyrest Black Medium rates around a 7 to 8 on the 10 point firmness scale. The plush comfort foams provide some initial cushioning before the firmer coils support the body.
This thicker, firmer feel may suit back and stomach sleepers who need extra support for proper spinal alignment. The tall coil system gives excellent support to the perimeter.
The layer of memory foam conforms to the body for some pressure relief on shoulders and hips. But many side sleepers may find the Beautyrest Black too firm to allow their curves to fully sink in.
Combination sleepers who change positions during the night are better able to stay comfortable on this firmer surface.
Temperature Regulation and Airflow
The moisture-wicking cover and gel-infused memory foam help dissipate heat and promote a cooler sleep environment compared to all-foam options. The coil layer also improves overall airflow.
Responsiveness and Bounce
The Beautyrest Black has excellent bounce and responsiveness from its array of pocketed coils. The coils compress where pressure is applied then spring back instantly when you change positions.
With its reinforced perimeter of high-density foam bolstering the coil support, the Beautyrest Black excels at edge support. The ample sleeping space lets you rest comfortably by the edge without “falling off” the mattress.
The pocketed coil design helps minimize noise, but some models have plastic reinforcements around the coils that may cause occasional sounds or squeaking, especially on the firmer options.
The responsive coils make it easy to change positions during amorous activities while the plush comfort layers cushion pressure points for comfort. Strong edge support also allows utilizing the entire sleep surface.
Off-gassing and Smell
Like most bed-in-a-box mattresses, some initial off-gassing may occur after unboxing. But any chemical-like smell from the foams should quickly dissipate.
Here are the Beautyrest Black’s ratings based on sleeper type:
Side Sleepers: 3/5 stars. May be overly firm and not pressure relieving enough for strict side sleepers.
Back Sleepers: 5/5 stars. Excellent lumbar support and healthy spine alignment.
Stomach Sleepers: 4.5/5 stars. Firmer feel keeps the abdomen lifted and supported.
Combination Sleepers: 4/5 stars. Responsive surface facilitates moving positions.
Plus-size Sleepers: 4.5/5 stars. Provides robust support for heavier individuals.
Helix Midnight Luxe vs Beautyrest Black: Which is the Best Mattress for You?
The Helix Midnight Luxe and Beautyrest Black offer premium hybrid mattresses with high-end features and materials. The main differences come down to:
- Firmness – Helix softer and more pressure relieving vs Beautyrest firmer and more supportive
- Sleep Position – Helix better for strict side sleepers while Beautyrest suits back sleepers
- Budget – Helix more affordable luxury option vs Beautyrest premium brand name model
- Customization – Helix more flexible overall with customization options
If you are a side sleeper wanting the closest contouring comfort with superior pressure relief, the Helix Midnight Luxe is likely the better choice for you.
For back sleepers who prefer a firmer, supportive mattress from an established luxury brand, the Beautyrest Black has compelling advantages.
No matter which mattress you decide on, take advantage of the 100-night risk-free trial offered by both brands to experience the bed in your unique sleep environment. Then, you can be confident you selected the perfect high-end mattress.
Mattress Buzz is reader supported. When you buy a product through our links we may earn an affiliate commission.