Table
When you’re shopping for a new mattress, Saatva and Casper often top the comparison lists for good reason. These brands represent two distinct approaches to sleep technology—traditional luxury craftsmanship versus modern foam innovation. You’ll notice significant differences in construction, feel, pricing, and delivery methods that directly impact your sleep experience. Understanding these key distinctions will help you determine which mattress aligns with your specific sleep position, comfort preferences, and budget requirements.
>>SAATVA MATTRESS 20% OFF CLICK HERE<<
Company Background and Brand Philosophy
When comparing two of the most recognized names in the online mattress industry, understanding their origins provides valuable context for your purchase decision.
Saatva, founded in 2010, pioneered the luxury online mattress model with an eco-conscious approach. Their philosophy centers on delivering premium materials and traditional craftsmanship without retail markups.
They’ve maintained a commitment to American manufacturing and white-glove delivery service.
Casper launched in 2014 as a direct-to-consumer disruptor with their innovative “bed-in-a-box” concept. Their brand philosophy emphasizes simplicity, accessibility, and science-backed design.
Casper’s research-driven approach has expanded beyond mattresses to extensive sleep solutions, including innovative technologies designed to optimize sleep conditions.
Both companies have revolutionized mattress shopping, but their foundational values and execution strategies differ considerably in ways that might influence your preferences.
Materials and Construction Comparison
When you’re comparing Saatva and Casper mattresses, their materials and construction reveal fundamental differences in design philosophy.
Saatva’s hybrid construction combines a coil-on-coil support system with memory foam comfort layers, creating a more traditional innerspring feel with added pressure relief.
Casper, meanwhile, uses a proprietary foam layering system with zoned support technology that provides targeted firmness where your body needs it most.
Layer Composition Analysis
Although both Saatva and Casper offer premium mattresses, their internal construction differs considerably in materials and design philosophy.
Saatva’s hybrid design features:
- Euro pillow top with organic cotton cover
- 3″ comfort layer combining memory foam and individually wrapped coils
- 4″ shift layer with lumbar support zone
- 7″ support core of tempered steel hourglass coils
Casper takes a foam-focused approach with:
- Breathable AirScape™ perforated foam top layer
- Zoned Support™ memory foam middle layer (firmer under hips, softer under shoulders)
- Durable high-density polyfoam base layer
- All-foam models range from 10″-12″ total height
- Hybrid versions add a 6″ pocketed coil system between foam layers
You’ll notice Saatva emphasizes traditional coil technology while Casper prioritizes innovative foam solutions.
Support System Differences
The support systems in Saatva and Casper mattresses represent fundamentally different engineering approaches to spinal alignment and pressure relief.
Saatva employs a dual-coil system that includes:
- A steel coil base layer (884-1,104 coils)
- A secondary coil layer (416 individually wrapped coils)
- Reinforced edge support with foam encasement
Casper, meanwhile, utilizes an all-foam or hybrid construction with:
- Zoned Support™ technology featuring three ergonomic zones
- Targeted gel pods in hybrid models for precise pressure relief
- Perimeter edge support through firmer foam borders
You’ll notice these differences most when changing sleeping positions.
Saatva’s coil-on-coil design provides responsive bounce and airflow, while Casper’s zoned approach delivers targeted compression where you need it most.
Comfort and Support Analysis
When comparing Saatva and Casper mattresses, you’ll notice significant differences in firmness levels, with Saatva offering multiple options ranging from plush soft to firm while Casper maintains a medium-firm feel across most models.
Your pressure relief needs will determine which brand serves you better—Saatva’s coil systems provide targeted support with a responsive feel, whereas Casper’s foam layers contour more closely to your body.
Side sleepers typically prefer Casper’s pressure-relieving properties, while back and stomach sleepers often favor Saatva’s stronger support structure and lumbar reinforcement.
Firmness Level Comparison
Comparing firmness levels between Saatva and Casper reveals fundamental differences in how these mattresses deliver comfort and support.
Saatva offers three distinct firmness options: Plush Soft (3/10), Luxury Firm (5-7/10), and Firm (8/10), allowing you to select precisely what suits your sleeping style.
Casper, meanwhile, takes a different approach with their one-firmness-fits-all design, rated around 5-6/10 on the firmness scale. Their proprietary Zoned Support™ system creates targeted firmness zones that adjust to different body areas.
You’ll find Saatva’s Luxury Firm option appeals to approximately 80% of sleepers, making it their bestseller.
If you’re a side sleeper under 130 pounds, Saatva’s Plush Soft provides gentler pressure relief, while back and stomach sleepers over 230 pounds benefit from Saatva’s Firm option.
Pressure Relief Preferences
Moving beyond firmness ratings, pressure relief capabilities greatly impact your overall comfort experience with both Saatva and Casper mattresses.
The Saatva excels at targeted pressure relief through its dual-coil system and lumbar zone enhancement.
You’ll notice enhanced support in the middle third of the mattress, which reduces lower back tension while maintaining proper spinal alignment.
Casper takes a different approach with its zoned support foam layer. This design offers softer cushioning under shoulders and firmer support beneath hips and core.
You’ll experience:
- More give in shoulder areas for side sleepers
- Balanced support for back sleepers
- Enhanced pressure distribution across contact points
Your preferred sleeping position should guide your choice—Saatva typically serves back and stomach sleepers better, while Casper’s zoned relief often benefits side and combination sleepers.
Sleeping Position Suitability
Depending on whether you sleep on your back, side, or stomach, your body requires different levels of support and pressure relief from a mattress. Both Saatva and Casper offer options that cater to different sleeping positions, but they excel in different areas.
| Position | Saatva | Casper |
|---|---|---|
| Side Sleepers | Luxury Plush model offers excellent pressure relief for shoulders and hips | Original model provides good contouring for pressure points |
| Back Sleepers | Firm and Luxury Firm options maintain proper spinal alignment | Medium-firm feel works well for most back sleepers |
| Stomach Sleepers | Firm model prevents excessive sinking of hips | Less ideal as some models may allow hip sinking |
The Saatva’s coil-on-coil construction delivers targeted support, particularly beneficial for back and stomach sleepers. Casper’s zoned support system performs exceptionally well for side sleepers and those with shoulder pain.
Price Point and Value Assessment
When evaluating mattresses, the price point often becomes a decisive factor for many shoppers. Saatva and Casper represent different value propositions in the mattress market.
Saatva typically costs more than Casper, with queen sizes ranging from $1,399-$3,295 depending on the model. This higher price reflects their luxury construction, including:
- Dual coil systems
- Organic cotton covers
- Free white glove delivery
Casper offers more budget-friendly options, with queen mattresses priced between $895-$2,895. Their value comes from:
- Proprietary foam technology
- More frequent sales and promotions
- 100-night sleep trial
You’ll need to weigh these price differences against your specific needs. While Saatva provides premium materials and services, Casper delivers quality at a more accessible price point.
Sleep Trial and Warranty Policies
Both Saatva and Casper understand that buying a mattress online requires strong customer assurances, which is why they’ve established extensive sleep trial and warranty policies.
Saatva offers a 180-night sleep trial with a $99 return fee, while Casper provides a 100-night trial with free returns. This gives you ample time to determine if either mattress meets your needs at home.
For long-term protection, Saatva backs their mattresses with a 15-year warranty that covers manufacturing defects and body impressions deeper than 1 inch.
Casper’s 10-year warranty similarly covers defects and indentations exceeding 1 inch.
The key difference lies in Saatva’s longer trial period and warranty, though they charge for returns.
Meanwhile, Casper’s shorter timeframes come with the advantage of hassle-free, cost-free returns.
Customer Satisfaction and Reviews
How do actual owners rate their Saatva and Casper mattresses after sleeping on them for months or even years? Both brands maintain strong reputations, but customer feedback reveals distinct differences in satisfaction areas.
| Aspect | Saatva | Casper |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Satisfaction | 4.8/5 | 4.6/5 |
| Durability | Higher ratings (7-10 years) | Mixed long-term reviews (5-7 years) |
| Motion Isolation | Good, not excellent | Excellent |
| Value for Money | Often cited as “worth the investment” | Frequently noted as “good quality for price” |
You’ll find Saatva customers consistently praise the luxurious feel and edge support, while Casper owners highlight pressure relief and minimal partner disturbance. Both brands receive positive feedback for customer service, though Saatva’s white glove delivery earns special mention in reviews.
Which Mattress Is Right for You?
Customer reviews offer valuable insights, but the ultimate question remains: which mattress will best serve your specific needs?
Choose Saatva if you:
- Prefer a traditional innerspring feel with added comfort layers
- Want multiple firmness options (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, Firm)
- Value enhanced edge support for sitting or getting in/out of bed
- Prefer white-glove delivery service
- Need a mattress that accommodates heavier body types
Opt for Casper if you:
- Prefer the pressure-relieving qualities of all-foam construction
- Sleep hot and need cooling technology
- Share your bed with a partner who moves frequently
- Want a bed-in-a-box convenience
- Have a tighter budget but still want quality construction
Your ideal choice depends on sleep position, body type, temperature preferences, and value priorities.
Conclusion
You’ll find yourself drawn to Saatva if you value traditional craftsmanship, prefer responsive bounce, and need sturdy edge support. You’re better suited for Casper if you’re a side sleeper looking for pressure relief, innovative foam technology, and convenient delivery. Your sleeping position and comfort preferences ultimately determine your ideal choice—Saatva’s luxury innerspring construction versus Casper’s adaptive foam design. Both offer quality, just through different approaches to your sleep needs.
Mattress Buzz is reader supported. When you buy a product through our links we may earn an affiliate commission.